Cosmo's Ristorante & Delicatessen

The food is always wonderful at Cosmo’s. We have been here quite a few times and decided to come here for our anniversary tonight. As usual, the food was great but what really made our dinner tonight was the service. Amber was our server. She was the only one in the restaurant serving and it was very busy. Not only was she quick and efficient, she was smiling and very pleasant- even though she was extremely busy. She was the highlight of our dinner tonight. We will definitely be back again and hope to see her as well. Job well done!

First the service was stupendous. We were there 3 pm on a Tuesday and the waitress had Saturday night energy. She made excellent cocktails (she built the most delicious and balanced margarita) and was quick with her trips to our table. I wish I had gotten her name to put here. We started with appetizers, the cheddar on the charcuterie plate gave me feelings and the simple collection of elements was perfect together.

IMO you can't beat Cosmo's atmosphere for a nice dinner night out. The decor is great and the service is always top notch. Food is a little overpriced but, such is life in WA. They are a made from scratch kitchen so sometimes you have to go with limited menu offerings but I've never been disappointed. Sometimes it's a little slow but this is a sit back and relax, savor your wine kind of place. I really appreciate what they offer the community - thank you!

Sadly, we left quite disappointed because based on all the other reviews we read, we were expecting to enjoy an excellent Italian lunch which was not what we experienced. Based on the menu items which were priced very high, we were very surprised that they do not offer cloth napkins and bottled sparkling water such as San Pelligrino. The interior decoration was quite old and out dated. Ordered the spaghetti and meatballs which was not very good at all. Sauce was not homemade but must have come from a bottle and the pasta was overcooked and not al dente like it should be. Salad was fresh but not anything out of the ordinary and sauces were definitely not homemade. We were also surprised that we were not offered any parmesan to sprinkle over the spaghetti or ravioli When we arrived, we were each given a glass of water which was simply local tap water with a definite after-taste. We asked for bottled water which our server delivered as 2 plastic water bottles with no glasses to pour it into. The mushroom ravioli was tasty but the portion served was not at all generous which I somewhat expected given the price of this menu item. The highlight of our lunch was the Ciabatta bread which was served warm and fresh; however, the butter came in a foil pouch cafeteria style! Needless to say, we will not be returning and we would not recommend this restaurant if you want reasonably priced delicious Italian food. There are many other places to choose from.

Been trying to find the hidden gems on the peninsula and was really hoping this would be one. The deli is cute, service is great and atmosphere is cozy and charming. The food was mediocre and overpriced. If I’m paying over $20 for lasagna I’d really hope it was cooked and the noodles on bottom weren’t hard, not much flavor either. $140 dinner for two with just a drink a piece - pass. Underwhelmed. We won’t be returning.

So, I have to knock my review down since going back a few times. There is a huge inconsistency in the sandwiches depending on who is working. Sometimes the sandwiches are really great and flavorful. Other times, it’s mostly bread and/or super bland without the flavor. I always get the same two sandwiches, so I know what it should taste like. Most recently went here today, 12/14 in the early evening, and whoever made the sandwiches this time did a horrific job. Probably going to go here a lot less.